How to choose a loyalty program for your restaurant

In short

To choose a restaurant loyalty program, start from how often your guests really come back: a diner regular may come every week, a family sit-down place sees most people once a month or less. A short punch card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, with a reward guests can picture (a free entrée, a dessert, a large pizza) and a punch added by a two-second scan at the register, fits most independent restaurants.

14 free days to try everything. Serve 30 customers in your first 14 days: 1 extra month free on your subscription.

Paid plans from $29 a month, excluding tax.

Example card

Where independent restaurants stand with loyalty

Most mom-and-pop restaurants already have regulars: the couple who takes the corner booth every Friday, the crew from the body shop who orders the lunch special, the family that does pizza night on Sundays. A loyalty program does not create those people. Its job is to give the next tier of guests, the ones who came twice and liked it, a reason to make it a habit.

The trouble is that restaurant loyalty is often copied from coffee shops. A coffee shop sees the same face every morning; a restaurant may see a good guest every three or four weeks. A twelve-box card that works for lattes can take a year to fill over enchiladas, and nobody finishes it.

What makes a restaurant different

  • A slow return rhythm. Guests come back in weeks, not days. The card has to be short enough to finish within a few months, or the reward feels out of reach and nobody talks about it.
  • Service cannot slow down. On a Friday rush, a server or the person on the register has seconds per check. Anything that needs typing, explaining or hunting for a stamp pad will be skipped, and a program that is skipped half the time dies quietly.
  • Delivery apps keep the customer. A guest who orders through a third-party app is that app’s customer: you rarely get a name or a phone number. A loyalty card handed over at the counter or in the takeout bag is one of the few ways to turn a delivery order into a direct relationship.

Loyalty mechanics compared for restaurants

Common loyalty mechanics and how they fit a restaurant
MechanicWorks best forThe limit
Paper punch cardA diner or taqueria with daily regularsLost in a pocket, easy to copy, and you never know who came back
Punch card in Apple Wallet or Google WalletMost independent restaurants, dine-in and takeoutNeeds a quick scan at the register on every visit
Points card (points per dollar spent)Places where a check ranges from a taco to a catering trayHarder to explain at the table than "ten visits"
Discount club or VIP percentage offRestaurants with high margins and a strong brandTrains guests to expect a discount on every check
Your own mobile appRestaurant groups with a marketing budgetFew guests download an app for a place they visit monthly
There is no single right answer: the mechanic follows your average check and how often a good guest returns.

Questions to ask before you choose

  • How often does a good guest come back? Look at your regulars honestly: weekly, twice a month, monthly?
  • What does a typical check look like? If it swings a lot (one burrito vs a family order), points by dollar spent may be fairer than a punch per visit.
  • Who adds the punch: the server at the table, or the cashier at the register? Pick one moment and train everyone on it.
  • Does it work for takeout? A guest picking up a to-go order should get the same punch as a guest eating in.
  • Can you change the reward later without reprinting anything? Your menu prices will move, and the reward should move with them.
  • Does the guest need to download an app or create a password? For a restaurant visited once a month, every extra step loses people.

The program I would set up in a restaurant

For a typical independent restaurant with a check around fifteen to thirty dollars per person, I would start with a short punch card in the guest’s phone wallet and a reward that sounds like a treat rather than a coupon.

  1. 01

    Eight boxes, the last one is the reward

    With the default rule in Passcard, the eighth box is the gift, so a guest gets it on the eighth visit after seven paid ones. You can switch the setting so the reward comes after the card is full if you prefer.

  2. 02

    A reward people can picture

    A free entrée up to a set price, a large pizza, or dessert for the table. Write it on the card exactly as you would say it.

  3. 03

    The QR code where people wait

    Put the sign-up QR poster by the register, on the host stand and on a small tent card on each table. Add a sticker on takeout bags so delivery and pickup guests can join too.

  4. 04

    One scan per check

    The cashier scans the guest’s card when the check is paid. If the guest forgot the phone, look them up by name or phone number.

  5. 05

    One message that brings people back

    Turn on the automatic message for guests who have not been back in a while, with something simple: "We miss you, the special this week is brisket."

A worked example in dollars

Say your average check is $22 and your food cost runs about 30% of the menu price (an assumption for the example; use your own numbers). The reward is an entrée worth up to $16, which costs you roughly $4.80 in food. Spread over the seven paid visits that earned it, that is under 70 cents a visit, or about 3% of what the guest spent with you in that period.

If the card brings even a handful of two-visit guests back for a third and fourth visit each month, it pays for its rewards many times over. Harvard Business Review (Amy Gallo, 2014) reports that acquiring a new customer can cost 5 to 25 times more than keeping an existing one.

Common mistakes

  • A card that is too long. Twelve punches at one visit a month is a year; most guests will never see the reward.
  • A reward that depends on the tip or the total with tax. Keep it simple: the punch counts the visit, the reward is a menu item.
  • Forgetting takeout and delivery guests. They are often the ones who would benefit most from a direct link to you.
  • Changing the rules without telling anyone. If you change the reward, send a message so guests do not feel tricked.

What Passcard does and does not do for a restaurant

Passcard puts a punch card or a points card in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet. Guests scan your QR code with the phone camera, fill a short form you design, and add the card in one tap: no app, no account, no password. Each punch is recorded with its date and the staff member who added it, and the card on the guest’s phone updates by itself.

It does not connect to your POS or your card reader, so it works with any register, and punches are added by a scan rather than automatically from a payment. It does not send text messages: messages show up on the card in the wallet. There is one plan in the United States, $29 a month or $290 a year, before any sales tax, with unlimited guests and cards, and 14 days free to try it. Your guests never pay anything.

Pricing

$29 per month

or $290 per year, 2 months free

Prices exclude tax.

Frequently asked questions

01

Stamps or points: which is better for a restaurant?

Stamps (punches per visit) are easier to explain and suit places where checks are similar. Points per dollar suit places where a check can be a single taco or a $200 catering order.

02

How many punches should a restaurant card have?

Usually eight to ten. Count how many visits a good regular makes in two or three months: the card should fill in about that time.

03

Should every person at the table get a punch?

Most restaurants punch per check, not per person, to keep it fast. If a table splits the check, each paying guest with a card can get a punch. Decide once and tell your staff.

04

Can delivery app customers join the program?

Yes, if you give them a way in: a sticker with your sign-up QR code on the takeout bag works well. The punch is added when they order directly from you or visit.

05

Do I need a new register or card reader?

No. Passcard does not plug into your POS. Your staff scans the guest’s card with a phone or a tablet at the counter, whatever register you use.

06

Can I send promotions by text message?

Passcard does not send SMS. Messages appear as notifications on the card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. Marketing texts in the US are regulated, so check your own obligations before running any SMS campaign.

Ready to launch your loyalty card?

Create your card
  • No app for your customers
  • Apple Wallet and Google Wallet
  • Set up in a few minutes