The loyalty card guide for Main Street businesses

In short

A loyalty card is a punch card or points card that rewards customers for coming back to the same small business. For most coffee shops, barbershops and taquerias the simplest version works best: eight to ten punches and one clear reward, on paper or in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet. Pick the format your staff can run at the register without slowing the line.

14 free days to try everything. Serve 30 customers in your first 14 days: 1 extra month free on your subscription.

Paid plans from $29 a month, excluding tax.

Example card

What a loyalty card really does for a small business

A loyalty card does not create customers. It gives the ones you already have a reason to pick you over the place across the street on an ordinary Tuesday. The customer who grabs a breakfast burrito on the way to work, the guy who gets a fade every three weeks, the family that orders pizza on Fridays: they already like you, and the card turns a habit into a small game with a finish line.

The economics behind it are well documented. Research by Frederick Reichheld at Bain & Company found that a 5% increase in customer retention was associated with profit increases of 25% to 95% in the industries studied. Harvard Business Review, summarizing the field in 2014, notes that acquiring a new customer can cost 5 to 25 times more than retaining an existing one. A mom-and-pop shop is not a bank or an insurer, so treat these numbers as a direction, not a promise for your register. The direction is still clear: a regular who comes back one more time a month is worth more than a stranger you paid to attract.

A good card also tells you something. When every punch is recorded, you learn who comes back, how often, and who quietly stopped coming. Paper cards can not tell you that, which is the main honest difference between the two formats.

The main formats, side by side

Loyalty card formats for US small businesses
FormatHow it worksBest forWatch out for
Paper punch cardA hole punch or rubber stamp on a printed cardStarting this week with almost no budgetLost cards, copied stamps, no customer data
Digital punch card in the walletThe card lives in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, staff scans itFrequent visits: coffee, lunch, haircutsNeeds a phone at the counter to scan
Points cardPoints per dollar spent, rewards at several levelsBaskets that vary a lot: diner, bakery, salon retailHarder to explain in one sentence
Discount or membership clubA fixed percent off for membersShops with high repeat spend and good marginsGives margin away on every visit
Branded appThe customer downloads your own appLarge chains with a marketing teamMost customers will not download an app for one shop

Which format fits which business

  • Coffee shop: a punch card, eight to ten punches, a free drink at the end. Visits are frequent and the ticket is small, so counting visits is fairer than counting dollars.
  • Taqueria or pizza place: a punch card per order, with a reward the whole table enjoys (a free order of chips and guac, a free medium pizza). If the check size swings a lot between a solo lunch and a family order, consider points.
  • Barbershop: a punch card on haircuts. Visits come every few weeks, so six to eight punches feels reachable; ten can feel like a year.
  • Nail salon: points often fit better because a quick polish change and a full set with art are very different tickets.
  • Bakery: a punch card for regulars who stop in every morning, with a reward that moves product you bake anyway (a dozen cookies, a loaf of the day).
  • Diner: points per dollar on the check, before tip, so a solo coffee and a Sunday brunch for four are both counted fairly.

Choosing a reward that pays for itself

The reward has to feel generous to the customer and cost you little. The trick is to give something with a high menu price and a low cost to make. A free drip coffee, a free side, a free beard trim: customers value them at the menu price, you pay for them at cost.

A worked example, with assumptions stated. Say a latte sells for $5.00 and costs you about $1.25 in milk, espresso, cup and lid. On a ten-box card where the last box is the reward (the default setting in Passcard, which you can change), the customer pays for nine lattes, or $45.00, and gets the tenth free. Your reward costs about $1.25, roughly 3% of what that customer spent with you during the card. If the card brings each regular in one extra time a month, it has paid for itself several times over.

Two US details to settle before you print anything. Sales tax on a free item is handled differently from state to state, so ask your accountant how to ring up a reward at your register. And in a sit-down place, decide whether servers keep their tip on a comped item: most customers tip on the menu value, and it is kinder to your staff to say so on the card or at the table.

Launching the card at the register

  1. 01

    Write one sentence

    Your staff needs a line they can say in three seconds: "Want our punch card? Tenth coffee is on us." If it takes longer, the reward is too complicated.

  2. 02

    Put the sign-up where people wait

    Next to the register, on the pickup counter, on the table tent. People sign up while they wait for their order, not while they pay.

  3. 03

    Give the first punch right away

    A card that starts with one punch already filled feels started, and customers are more likely to finish something they have begun.

  4. 04

    Tell the team why

    Explain that the card is there to keep regulars, not to upsell. Staff who believe in it offer it to everyone; staff who do not, forget.

  5. 05

    Check after four weeks

    Look at how many people joined, how many came back with their card, and whether anyone has finished a card yet. Adjust the number of boxes if nobody is close.

Common mistakes

  • Too many boxes. A twenty-punch card for a weekly visit means five months before a reward. Most people give up before then.
  • A reward nobody wants. A free bottle of water is not a reward. Pick something you would be happy to receive yourself.
  • Fine print. "Excludes specialty drinks, weekends and holidays" kills the goodwill the card was supposed to build.
  • Forgetting the slow days. A double-punch Tuesday can fill a quiet afternoon better than any flyer.
  • Collecting more data than you use. If you never send birthday messages, do not ask for a birthday.

How Passcard runs a loyalty card

Passcard puts your punch card or points card in Apple Wallet on iPhone and Google Wallet on Android. The customer scans your sign-up QR code with the phone camera, fills a short form you designed, and taps one button to add the card. No app to install, no account, no password.

To add a punch, your staff scans the QR code on the customer’s card with the shop phone or a tablet at the counter, or looks the customer up by name or phone number. The card on the customer’s phone updates by itself. A 10-second cooldown between two punches on the same customer prevents accidental double scans, and several punches at once (three coffees for the office) are added on purpose.

There is one plan in the United States: $29 a month or $290 a year, before any sales tax, with unlimited customers and cards. New businesses get 14 days free. Your customers never pay anything.

What Passcard does not do

  • No app for your customers to download, and no plastic cards to order.
  • No text messages: messages appear as notifications on the card in the wallet.
  • No link to your card reader or POS. It works next to any register, and punches are added by a scan, not automatically when someone pays.

Pricing

$29 per month

or $290 per year, 2 months free

Prices exclude tax.

Frequently asked questions

01

How many punches should my loyalty card have?

For visits once or twice a week, eight to ten punches is the usual range. For visits every few weeks, like a barbershop, six to eight is easier to finish. The goal is a reward the customer can reach within two or three months.

02

Is the last box the reward or does the reward come after the card is full?

Both work. In Passcard the default is that the last box is the reward, so a ten-box card rewards the tenth visit after nine paid ones. You can switch so the reward comes after the card is full.

03

Do my customers need to download an app?

No. The card goes into Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, which are already on the phone. The customer scans a QR code, fills a short form and taps one button.

04

Do I charge sales tax on a free reward?

It depends on your state and on how you ring the reward up. Rules differ across the country, so check with your accountant or your state’s tax agency before you launch.

05

Can I keep my paper punch cards while I switch?

Yes. Many shops run both for a few weeks. When a customer brings a paper card, staff adds the same number of punches to the digital card and keeps the paper one.

06

What does it cost?

Passcard has one plan in the United States: $29 a month or $290 a year, before any sales tax, with unlimited customers and cards, and 14 days free to start.

07

What if a customer deletes the card from their phone?

You can no longer update it on that phone, but their history stays on your side. They scan your QR code again to get the card back.

Ready to launch your loyalty card?

Create your card
  • No app for your customers
  • Apple Wallet and Google Wallet
  • Set up in a few minutes