Points loyalty card: when points beat a punch card

In short

A points loyalty card gives customers points for every dollar they spend and lets them trade those points for rewards at several levels. Points beat a punch card when your checks vary a lot, like a diner, a nail salon or a bakery that sells both single cookies and custom cakes. When every visit costs about the same, a punch card is simpler.

14 free days to try everything. Serve 30 customers in your first 14 days: 1 extra month free on your subscription.

Paid plans from $29 a month, excluding tax.

Example card

Punches count visits, points count dollars

A punch card rewards frequency: one visit, one punch, whatever the customer bought. That is perfect for a coffee shop where almost everyone spends between four and seven dollars. It becomes unfair when one customer spends $6 on a slice and a soda and another spends $60 on a family dinner, and both get the same single punch.

A points card rewards spending. The customer who orders for the whole office moves faster than the one who buys one donut, and both still see progress. The cost is a little more explaining at the register, and a card that is not as instantly readable as ten boxes.

Punch card or points card
QuestionPunch cardPoints card
What it countsVisitsDollars spent
Best whenChecks are similar every timeChecks vary a lot from visit to visit
Explained in one lineEasily: "Tenth visit free"Harder: "A point per dollar, rewards from 50 points"
RewardsUsually one rewardA menu of rewards at several levels
Staff action at the counterScan the cardScan the card and enter the amount

When points are the better choice

  • Your average check swings widely: a diner with solo coffees on weekdays and brunch for four on Sundays.
  • You sell both services and products: a nail salon where a client might add cuticle oil or a gift set to the appointment.
  • You want to reward big orders without giving away a free item every few visits: catering trays, party orders, birthday cakes.
  • Your regulars like choice: some want a small treat soon, others prefer to save up for something bigger.

How many points per dollar?

Keep the earning rule round and easy to say. One point per dollar spent is the clearest rule in the US: customers can check it in their heads against the receipt. Decide up front whether points are earned on the subtotal before sales tax and before tip; most businesses use the pre-tax subtotal, and leaving the tip out keeps servers’ tips separate from your marketing.

Then work backward from what a reward costs you. A worked example for a diner, with assumptions stated: say the average check is $22, food cost is around 30% of menu price, and you want to give back about 4% of what a customer spends in reward value at menu price. At one point per dollar, a customer reaches 100 points after roughly four or five average visits, or about $100 spent. Four percent of $100 is $4 of menu value: a free bottomless coffee or a slice of pie. Because you pay for that pie at cost, not at menu price, the real expense is closer to $1.20, a little over 1% of what that customer spent with you.

Change any of those assumptions and the numbers change with them. The method is what matters: decide the share of spending you want to give back, then set the point levels so the math lands there.

Building a tiered rewards menu

A good catalog has three or four levels. The first is reachable in two or three visits so nobody feels stuck at zero. The top one is generous enough that a regular talks about it.

  • 50 points: a drink, a side or a cookie. Cheap to make, reached fast, gets people into the habit.
  • 100 points: an appetizer, a dessert, a basic polish change. The level most customers will actually use.
  • 200 points: an entree, a dozen bagels, a gel manicure. Something people save up for.
  • 400 points: a pizza party for four, a pedicure, a custom cake. Rare, but it gives the card a story.

Common mistakes with points

  • Points that are worth nothing. Ten points per dollar with a first reward at 2,000 points looks big and feels like nothing. Keep numbers small and human.
  • Earning on tips. It mixes your staff’s money with your marketing budget. Earn on the subtotal.
  • A single top reward. If the only reward is at 500 points, most customers never see one.
  • Changing the rules quietly. If you change point levels, tell customers on the card first. Trust is the whole point of the program.
  • Using points where punches would do. A coffee cart with a $5 average check gains nothing from points except a slower line.

How points work in Passcard

You choose stamps or points when you create the card. In points mode, your staff scans the QR code on the customer’s card and enters the amount of the purchase; the points are credited according to the rule you set, and the card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet shows the new balance by itself. Your rewards catalog can have several levels, and the customer sees what they can claim.

As with punches, a 10-second cooldown between two credits on the same customer prevents a double scan from counting the same check twice. Every credit is recorded with its date and the staff member who added it, so you can see who comes back and how much they spend over time.

Passcard has one plan in the United States: $29 a month or $290 a year, before any sales tax, unlimited customers and cards, punches or points. New businesses get 14 days free.

What a points card in Passcard does not do

  • It does not read amounts from your card reader or POS: staff enters the amount when scanning. It works next to any register.
  • It does not need an app on the customer’s phone, and it does not send text messages.
  • It does not turn points into cash or store credit: points unlock the rewards you put in your catalog.

Pricing

$29 per month

or $290 per year, 2 months free

Prices exclude tax.

Frequently asked questions

01

Should a small business use points or punches?

Use punches if most visits cost about the same, like coffee or haircuts. Use points if checks vary a lot, like a diner, a nail salon or a bakery that also sells custom cakes.

02

How many points per dollar should I give?

One point per dollar is the easiest rule to explain. Then set reward levels so the value you give back is a small, deliberate share of what customers spend, worked out from your own food or product cost.

03

Should points count sales tax and tips?

Most businesses award points on the subtotal before sales tax and leave tips out entirely. It keeps the math simple and keeps your staff’s tips separate from your rewards.

04

Can I offer several rewards on one card?

Yes. A points card in Passcard has a rewards catalog with several levels, from a small treat for a few points to a bigger reward for more.

05

Can I switch a punch card to points later?

The mode is chosen when you create a card. If you change your mind, create a new points card and invite your regulars to join it, and honor the punches they already earned so nobody feels they lost their progress.

06

How do I explain points to customers in a hurry?

Use one line with the earning rule and the first reward: "A point per dollar, a free coffee at 50." Customers can discover the bigger rewards on the card later.

07

Does the customer see their points balance?

Yes. The balance shows on the card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet and updates by itself after each credit.

Ready to launch your loyalty card?

Create your card
  • No app for your customers
  • Apple Wallet and Google Wallet
  • Set up in a few minutes