How much does a loyalty program cost a small business?

In short

A loyalty program costs a small business four things: the tool (paper cards or software), the rewards you give away, a little printing and some staff time at the counter. For most Main Street shops the biggest line is the rewards, and it stays small when the reward is something cheap to make with a high menu price. A program pays off if it brings regulars back a few extra times a year.

14 free days to try everything. Serve 30 customers in your first 14 days: 1 extra month free on your subscription.

Paid plans from $29 a month, excluding tax.

Example card

The four lines of the budget

Cost lines of a small business loyalty program
Cost linePaper punch cardDigital card with Passcard
ToolPrint runs and a hole punch or stamp$29 a month or $290 a year, before any sales tax
RewardsYour cost to make the free itemYour cost to make the free item
PrintingEvery card, every redesignOne QR poster, provided as a PDF
Staff timeA punch at checkoutA scan at checkout
Hidden costsLost cards, copied stampsA phone or tablet at the counter if you do not have one

Software: what to budget

Passcard has one plan in the United States: $29 a month, or $290 if you pay for the year, before any sales tax. It includes unlimited customers and unlimited cards, punches or points, and the sign-up QR poster. New businesses get 14 days free, so you can see whether customers sign up before paying anything. Your customers never pay.

There is no hardware to buy if your shop already has a smartphone or a tablet: staff scans customer cards with it, or you pair a device as a fixed scanning station at the counter. There is no POS integration to pay for, because Passcard works next to any register.

Rewards: the line that really matters

Reward cost is easy to overestimate because people think in menu prices. Count it in what the reward costs you to make or buy.

A worked example for a pizza place, with assumptions stated. Say a large pizza sells for $20 and costs you about $5 in dough, cheese, toppings and box. On a ten-box card where the last box is the free pizza (the default, which you can change), the customer pays for nine pizzas, $180, and gets the tenth on the house. Your reward costs about $5, under 3% of what that customer spent during the card. Even if you add sales tax handling and a few cards that are never finished, the reward stays a small share of revenue from your best customers.

Compare that with a 10% discount on every visit: on the same nine pizzas you would give back $18 at menu price, every one of those dollars coming straight out of margin. That is why most small businesses prefer a free item over a percentage off.

Printing and staff time

With paper, printing never stops: new cards when the box runs out, new cards when the design or the reward changes. With a digital card, you print the QR poster once, and the code stays valid when you change the reward, the number of boxes or the colors.

If you go with paper, ask your print shop for a quote on thick card stock: thin cards tear in wallets within weeks, and a torn card is a lost regular. If you go digital, the only printing worth paying for is a sturdy counter sign or a window sticker with your QR code, which lasts as long as you want since the code never changes.

Staff time is about the same in both cases: a few seconds per customer at checkout. The cost to watch is the time it takes when the process is unclear. A one-line pitch and a scanning device always at the same spot by the register keep it to a few seconds.

Hidden costs nobody mentions

  • Copied punches. A rubber stamp can be bought by anyone, and a few fake cards a month add up. A digital card only gets punches from a staff scan.
  • Staff giving punches to friends. Every punch in Passcard is recorded with who added it.
  • Lost cards and unhappy regulars who lose a nearly full card.
  • Unused data. Collecting customer details has a cost: privacy obligations. US rules vary by state, with California’s CCPA among the best known, and commercial email falls under the federal CAN-SPAM Act. Only collect what you will use, and check your own obligations.
  • Text message costs. Some programs rely on texting, which costs per message and is regulated. Passcard sends no text messages: messages appear on the card in the wallet.

When does a loyalty program break even?

The question is simple: does the program bring in more extra profit than it costs? Research by Frederick Reichheld at Bain & Company found that a 5% increase in customer retention was associated with profit increases of 25% to 95% in the industries studied, and Harvard Business Review notes that acquiring a new customer can cost 5 to 25 times more than keeping one. Your own break-even depends on your margins, so do the math with your numbers.

A worked example with stated assumptions: say your average check is $15 with a gross margin of about $9, and you pay $29 a month for the software. Divide $29 by $9 and you get the number of extra visits per month the program needs to cover itself. For most small businesses that is a handful of extra visits across all your regulars combined, not per customer. Add the cost of rewards claimed and you have your full monthly break-even.

How to keep costs under control

  • Pick a reward with a high menu price and a low cost: a drink, a side, a dessert, a trim.
  • Keep 8 to 10 punches for frequent visits, fewer for visits every few weeks.
  • Avoid percentage discounts for every member on every visit.
  • Use automatic messages for specific moments (birthday, customers who stopped coming) rather than frequent blasts.
  • Review figures every month: rewards claimed, returns, members who stopped coming.

Pricing

$29 per month

or $290 per year, 2 months free

Prices exclude tax.

Frequently asked questions

01

How much does a loyalty program cost a small business?

With Passcard, the software is $29 a month or $290 a year, before any sales tax. On top of that, count the cost to make your rewards, which is usually a small share of what members spend, plus a printed QR poster.

02

Do I need to buy hardware?

Usually not. Passcard works with the phone or tablet you already have and next to any register, with no POS integration. New businesses get 14 days free.

03

What is the biggest cost of a loyalty program?

Usually the rewards. Keep them affordable by choosing items with a high menu price and a low cost to make.

04

Is a free item cheaper than a discount?

Usually yes. A free item costs you what it costs to make, while a percentage discount on every visit comes straight out of margin on a full check.

05

Does Passcard charge per customer?

No. The single plan includes unlimited customers and cards. Messages appear on the card in the wallet, so there are no text message fees either.

06

How do I know if my program is paying off?

Compare the extra visits from members with the monthly cost of the software and rewards. Passcard shows who comes back and how often, so you can check with real figures.

07

Is paying by the year cheaper?

Passcard offers $290 a year as an alternative to $29 a month, before any sales tax. Compare the two against how long you plan to run the program.

08

Do my customers pay anything?

No. Customers never pay to join or use the card.

Ready to launch your loyalty card?

Create your card
  • No app for your customers
  • Apple Wallet and Google Wallet
  • Set up in a few minutes