Stamp card or points card: which suits your shop?

How loyalty worksWritten by the Passcard team7 min read

In short

It comes down to one question: does a customer spend roughly the same each visit, or does it swing? If they spend about the same, like a flat white or a loaf, a stamp card is simpler: one visit, one stamp. If spend varies a lot, as in a restaurant, a salon with a long price list or a florist, points are fairer: for example one point per pound. Plenty of shops run both on different cards.

14 free days to try everything. Serve 30 customers in your first 14 days: 1 extra month free on your subscription.

Paid plans from £19 a month, excluding tax.

The stamp card: simple and easy to read

A stamp card works on a principle everyone understands in a second: one visit, one stamp, and after a set number of stamps the reward drops. There is nothing to calculate and nothing to explain at the till. The customer sees exactly where they are and how far they have to go.

That clarity is its strength. A box that fills up at each visit gives people a concrete reason to come back and fill the next one, which is why stamp cards suit shops people visit often and where each visit is worth roughly the same: the coffee shop, the bakery, the sandwich bar, the dry cleaner’s, the barber’s with one standard cut.

The weakness shows as soon as spend varies. With stamps, the customer who buys a £2.80 coffee and the one who orders lunch for four get exactly the same stamp. Where everyone spends about the same, that does not matter. Where the bill can be ten times bigger from one visit to the next, it starts to feel unfair, and your biggest spenders are rewarded no better than anyone else.

  • One visit equals one stamp: a clear, visual goal.
  • Best when spend is steady (café, bakery, sandwich bar, barber’s with one price).
  • Weak when spend varies: a £3 sale and a £30 sale earn the same stamp.

The points card: in step with what people spend

A points card measures loyalty in money rather than visits. The customer earns points according to what they spend, typically one point per pound (or per £2, or per £5 if baskets are large), and the reward unlocks at a points threshold. You enter the amount at the till and the points follow.

It is the right choice when the bill changes from one visit to the next: a restaurant where some come for a quick lunch and others for a birthday dinner, a hair salon where a trim and a full colour are very different prices, a florist, a wine shop, a gift shop. Points reward people in proportion to what they bring you, which is fairer, and a bigger basket moves the customer closer to the reward, which nudges spending in the right direction.

The trade off is that points are a little less visual than stamps. Customers follow a counter rather than watching boxes fill. In practice, when spend varies a lot, the fairness is worth more than the small loss of fun. And a points balance can be shown on the card itself: Google’s documentation for Wallet loyalty cards describes a points balance displayed on the pass, so the customer always knows where they stand.

The motivation works the same way in both systems. Research by Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng found that people speed up as they get closer to a reward. Whether the goal is a tenth stamp or a 100 point threshold, what keeps customers coming back is seeing the gap close.

  • One point per pound (or per £X), reward at a points threshold.
  • Best when spend varies (restaurant, salon with a long price list, florist, gift shop).
  • Fairer and finer grained, slightly less visual than stamps.

Decide in thirty seconds

If you need to decide quickly, two questions do almost all the work: how steady is your average spend, and what do you want to reward, the habit of coming in or the amount spent? Ask them in that order and the answer usually appears on its own.

In most cases the first question settles it. The others only matter for the in between cases, where part of your business is a fixed price item and part is not.

Stamps or points: quick comparison for a UK local shop
QuestionStampsPoints
Spend per visitRoughly the same each timeVaries a lot
What you rewardComing back oftenMoney spent with you
How it reads to customersBoxes that fill upA running total
Typical UK shopsCoffee shop, bakery, sandwich bar, barber’sRestaurant, hair salon, florist, wine shop
Main riskUnfair if baskets varyOverkill if every sale is the same

Examples from the high street

Take a coffee shop in Bristol where nearly every sale is a hot drink between £2.80 and £3.80. Stamps are the obvious choice: one drink, one stamp, tenth one free. Now take a bistro in Manchester where lunch is a set menu but dinner can run to five times that. Points work better there, unless the shop mostly sells the set lunch, in which case a stamp card for the lunch menu is perfectly sensible.

Salons are the in between case. A barber’s in Leeds with one standard cut and a beard trim can use stamps happily. A hair salon in Cardiff where a trim, a colour and a set of extensions sit at very different prices will find points fairer. A nail salon sits in the middle: if most clients book the same gel manicure, stamps are fine; if the menu is wide, go for points.

When in doubt, look at what makes up most of your takings and choose for that. You can always add a second card later for the other part of the business.

  • Coffee shop, bakery, sandwich bar, dry cleaner’s: stamps.
  • Restaurant or bistro: points, or stamps if you mainly sell a set menu.
  • Barber’s, hair or nail salon: stamps if one service dominates, points if the menu is varied.
  • Florist, wine shop, gift shop: points.

Mistakes to avoid

The first mistake is choosing points because they sound more professional. If every sale is a £3 coffee, points add a calculation with no benefit: customers have to work out that 30 points is a free drink when “ten stamps” would have said it plainly. Pick the simplest mechanic that is fair for your shop.

The second is picking an awkward conversion rate. One point per pound is understood instantly. One point per £1.75, or rewards at 437 points, makes people suspicious. Keep the ratio round and the threshold round too.

The third is switching mechanic on a card that is already running. A customer who has been collecting stamps and suddenly finds a points balance has no idea where they stand. If you want to change, start a new card and let the old one run out.

  • Do not use points just because they sound grander.
  • Keep the ratio round: one point per pound, or per £5 for larger baskets.
  • Never switch a running card from stamps to points: start a new card instead.

Can you run both?

Yes. Nothing locks you into one choice, and a good loyalty tool lets you pick the mechanic card by card. Passcard handles both stamps and points, so a café that also does evening meals can keep a stamp card for hot drinks and run a points card for the kitchen, each with its own reward.

Whatever the mechanic, the card sits in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet on the customer’s phone and updates itself after each visit, so there is nothing for them to calculate. They see their stamps or their points total, and a notification on the lock screen when a reward is ready.

Once you have picked the mechanic, the next step is setting the threshold: how many stamps, or how many points, before the reward. That has its own guide.

Frequently asked questions

01

Stamps or points for a restaurant?

For most restaurants, points are the better fit because the bill varies so much: a quick weekday lunch for one and a Saturday dinner for six are very different amounts. Points reward the real spend, so your best customers progress fastest. Stamps only make sense again if you mainly sell a set menu or a fixed price meal deal, where each visit is worth about the same and a simple “sixth lunch free” is easier to follow.

02

Are points more complicated for customers?

Hardly. The customer does nothing extra: they show their card, you enter the amount, and the points are added automatically. The only difference is that they follow a running total rather than boxes filling up. It is a bit less visual, but just as easy to understand, especially with a round ratio such as one point per pound. Nobody at the till or in the queue has to do any arithmetic.

03

How many points per pound should I give?

One point per pound is the most common and the easiest to grasp: the customer reads their total and knows what they have spent. If your baskets are large, one point per £5 keeps the numbers manageable. Then set the reward threshold so it lands within a sensible number of visits for a typical customer. Whatever you choose, keep it round. A ratio people can check in their head builds trust in the scheme.

04

Can I switch from stamps to points later?

Yes, but on a new card rather than the one customers are already filling. Switching a running card leaves people confused about what they have earned, and confusion turns into complaints at the till. Launch the points card for new sign ups, keep honouring the stamp cards in progress, and let them run their course. Within a few months most regulars will have moved across naturally.

Ready to launch your loyalty card?

Create my card for free
  • No app for your customers
  • Apple Wallet and Google Wallet
  • Set up in a few minutes