Switching from a paper loyalty card to digital: what happens to the stamps already given?

Going digitalWritten by the Passcard team7 min read

In short

You can move to a digital card without anyone losing a stamp. Pick a start date, transfer each customer’s existing stamps onto their new card the next time they come in (or give everyone a small welcome bonus), and accept paper cards alongside digital for a month or two. The one thing not to do is start everyone from zero: that punishes your best regulars.

14 free days to try everything. Serve 30 customers in your first 14 days: 1 extra month free on your subscription.

Paid plans from £19 a month, excluding tax.

Nobody has to lose their stamps

The biggest worry for shops thinking of going digital is the stack of paper cards already out there: the regular who has eight stamps on a dog eared card in their wallet, the customer who keeps theirs in a phone case. Starting them from zero would feel like a slap in the face. The good news is that you do not have to.

The switch happens one customer at a time, at the till, over the normal course of business. When a regular comes in with a half full paper card, you sign them up to the digital card and add the same number of stamps. They had seven, they leave with seven on their phone. They lose nothing, and they gain a card they cannot leave in yesterday’s coat.

There is no big switchover day. Each customer moves across on their next visit, and the paper system fades out on its own once the last stragglers have been in.

  • No reset: carry over the count from the paper card.
  • Customers switch one by one, on their next visit.
  • They gain a card that cannot be lost or left at home.

Step by step

The changeover takes four steps that you can start in a day and then let run for a few weeks. The aim is that neither you nor your staff have to think about it: everyone at the till knows what to do with a paper card.

The step that needs the most thought is the second one. Copying the exact count is the fairest option, but it slows the queue a little when each card has to be read. A flat welcome bonus is quicker and feels generous. Whichever you choose, write it down and tell everyone who works the till, so a customer on Saturday gets the same answer as a customer on Tuesday.

  • 1. Create your digital card and put the QR code by the till.
  • 2. Decide how to carry stamps over: either the exact number on the paper card, or a flat welcome bonus for everyone who switches (for example three free stamps).
  • 3. Run both side by side for a short period, typically one to two months, and keep honouring paper cards.
  • 4. Announce an end date for paper once most regulars have moved across.
Two ways to carry over paper stamps
OptionHow it worksBest for
Exact transferAdd the number of stamps shown on the paper cardShops with a lot of regulars mid card
Welcome bonusEveryone who switches gets the same head start, for example three stampsBusy counters where speed matters more than precision
BothTransfer the exact count, with a minimum bonus for those with fewer stampsShops that want to be generous and fair

Why a head start works so well

The welcome bonus is not just a kind gesture, it is backed by research. In the car wash experiment by Nunes and Drèze, customers given a ten stamp card with two stamps already filled completed it far more often than those given an empty eight stamp card, 34% against 19%, even though both had eight washes to go. A card that has already started feels worth finishing.

That is exactly what happens when you carry over paper stamps: the new digital card does not start empty, it starts part way through. Rather than feeling like a new scheme to learn, it feels like the old one continuing, only easier.

What to say at the till

The switch comes down to one sentence when you go to stamp the card. Something like: “We’ve moved the loyalty card onto your phone. Give me your paper one and I’ll carry your stamps over.” It is short, it reassures, and it makes clear the customer loses nothing.

Talk about what they gain, not what it saves you: no card to dig out of a purse, no card lost in the wash, and a message on their phone when a reward is waiting. With Passcard the customer scans a QR code, fills in a short form and adds the card to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. There is no app to download and no account to create.

If you are worried about older customers, show them. The card goes into the Wallet app already on their iPhone or Android phone, the same place some of them keep a boarding pass or a railcard. You can do the scan with them the first time; it takes less time than finding the paper card.

  • One simple line: “give me your paper card and I’ll carry your stamps over”.
  • Lead with the benefit to them: faster, nothing to lose, reminders when a reward is ready.
  • Older customers: no app to install, the Wallet is already on the phone.

What to do with the old cards and the counter display

Once the switch is under way, change the display by the till. A small sign saying “New loyalty card: scan here” next to the card machine is enough to tell regulars about the change and to sign up new customers straight onto digital, so you stop handing out paper.

Keep the old stamp and a few paper cards for a while longer. There will always be the customer who only comes in every couple of months and turns up with a half full card long after you have forgotten about them. You can carry their stamps over calmly rather than improvising.

When paper cards become rare, put the stamp away for good. There is no need for a hard deadline; your customers’ own rhythm tells you when paper has really gone.

Mistakes to avoid

The fatal one is a reset. Announcing “we’ve got a new system, the old cards don’t count any more” punishes your most loyal customers, the very people the scheme is meant to thank. It turns good news into a grievance and it will be mentioned to you, at length, in the queue.

The second is a deadline that is too short. Two weeks is not long enough for customers who visit monthly. A barber’s or a hair salon needs to cover at least one full cycle of appointments, which can mean two months; a coffee shop will see most regulars within a few weeks.

The third is saying nothing and switching everyone on the same busy Saturday. Tell people at the till, put up a sign, and let the change happen gradually. A switch that runs alongside normal service never jams the queue.

  • Never reset: carry over or give a head start.
  • Allow at least one full visit cycle before ending paper.
  • Tell customers, and switch gradually rather than all at once.

What the digital card does not do for you

A digital card does not transfer stamps by itself. Someone at the till still has to read the paper card and add the stamps, so brief your staff before you start, and decide in advance what to do when a card is illegible or obviously generous with the stamps. A simple house rule saves awkward moments.

It also does not fix a scheme that was never working. If nobody completed the paper card because it needed twenty stamps, carrying those stamps over to a twenty stamp digital card changes very little. Use the switch as a chance to check the number of stamps and the reward, and set the new card up properly.

Finally, if you plan to send marketing emails or text messages to customers, the usual UK rules on electronic marketing still apply, whatever the card is made of. Notifications through the Wallet and promotional messages are different things; check what consent you need before sending promotions.

Frequently asked questions

01

Do I have to carry over the exact number of stamps?

No, but it is the fairest and most reassuring option: you copy the count from the paper card. A flat welcome bonus for everyone who switches, such as three free stamps, is quicker at a busy counter and comes across as a nice gesture. You can also combine the two. What matters is that nobody walks away with fewer stamps than they had on their paper card.

02

How long should I run paper and digital side by side?

One to two months is usually enough. The period should cover at least one full visit cycle for your regulars. A coffee shop will see most of them within a few weeks, whereas a hair salon whose clients come every six to eight weeks needs a little longer. Match the period to how often your customers actually come in, and keep the old stamp handy for late arrivals after that.

03

Will older customers cope with a card on their phone?

More easily than many shop owners expect. There is no app to download and no account to set up: the card goes into the Wallet app that is already on their phone, the one that may hold a boarding pass or a railcard. One scan at the till does it, and you can help the first time. For many it is simpler than finding a paper card in a purse.

04

What if a customer has lost their paper card?

It happens, and it is one of the best arguments for going digital. Go by what the customer remembers, or simply give them a few starter stamps as a goodwill gesture. Once they are on the digital card, they cannot lose it again: it stays on their phone, and you can see their visits in your dashboard.

Ready to launch your loyalty card?

Create my card for free
  • No app for your customers
  • Apple Wallet and Google Wallet
  • Set up in a few minutes