Paper vs digital loyalty card: which one for your shop?

In short

A paper loyalty card is cheap, familiar and needs no technology, but it gets lost, can be stamped dishonestly and tells you nothing about who comes back. A digital loyalty card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet stays in the customer’s phone, records every visit with its date and lets you send messages, for a monthly fee. Paper is enough for a very small shop with a handful of regulars; digital pays off once you want to know and keep your regulars.

14 free days to try everything. Serve 30 customers in your first 14 days: 1 extra month free on your subscription.

Paid plans from £19 a month, excluding tax.

Example card

Paper cards deserve some credit

The little printed card with a rubber stamp has served British cafés, barbers and sandwich shops for decades, and for good reasons. Everybody understands it. It costs pennies. It needs no Wi-Fi, no phone and no training. An older customer who does not use a smartphone can still take part.

If you run a small shop with a few dozen loyal regulars you know by name, a paper card may be all you need. Switching to digital is not a moral obligation: it is a choice to make when the paper card starts to cost you more than it saves.

Where paper falls short

  • Cards get lost, left in coat pockets or washed with the jeans, and the customer starts again or gives up.
  • A rubber stamp can be copied, or a friendly member of staff can add two stamps instead of one. You have no way of knowing.
  • You learn nothing: you do not know who comes back, how often, or who has stopped coming.
  • You cannot reach a customer between visits, to announce a new menu or remind them that their reward is waiting.
  • Every change of reward or design means a new print run, and old cards in circulation with the old rules.

Paper vs digital, side by side

Paper stamp card compared with a digital Wallet card
CriterionPaper cardDigital card (Apple and Google Wallet)
CostPrinting and stamps, low but recurringMonthly subscription, unlimited cards
Lost cardsCommon, progress lostCard stays in the phone; rescan the QR code if deleted
FraudStamps easy to copy or addEach stamp recorded with date and staff member
Customer dataNoneWho comes back and how often, with the fields you choose
MessagesNot possibleNotifications on the card, including automatic ones
Customers without a smartphoneIncludedNot included: keep a few paper cards if needed

A year of costs: a worked example

Here is a hypothetical café, with assumptions stated so you can swap in your own figures. Say it prints 1,000 paper cards at a time for £40, plus £15 for a custom rubber stamp and ink. Say it gets through two print runs a year because cards are lost and the design changes once: that is about £95 a year in printing.

Now the less visible cost. Suppose one stamp in twenty is "extra", copied or added out of kindness, on a card that gives a free coffee costing the café £0.90 to make after nine paid visits. If the café hands out 300 free coffees a year, around 15 of them were never earned: about £13. Small, but it is pure loss, and you will never see it on paper.

The digital card costs £19 a month excluding VAT, or £190 a year, with unlimited cards and customers. So the printing saving alone will not pay for it in a small café. What pays for it is what paper cannot do: knowing which regulars have stopped coming and bringing a few of them back with a message, plus fewer abandoned cards. If two or three lapsed regulars return each month and buy a coffee and a pastry a week, the subscription is covered. Do this sum with your own average basket.

What customers notice

For the customer, the difference is mostly about not having to think. A paper card has to be in the wallet on the right day; a phone almost always is. Many people already open Apple Wallet or Google Wallet to pay or to show a train ticket, so the loyalty card sits where their hand is going anyway.

Customers also see their progress without asking. The card shows the stamps already collected, updates by itself after a scan and can carry a message from you, such as your Bank Holiday opening hours. On the other hand, some customers simply like a paper card in a purse, and a few will never sign up for anything on their phone. Neither group is wrong, which is why keeping a few paper cards during the switch makes sense.

When paper is still enough

  • You have few regulars and you know them all by name.
  • Most of your customers do not carry a smartphone, as in some rural shops or markets.
  • You only want a simple "tenth one free" and have no intention of contacting customers.
  • You are testing whether a loyalty scheme interests your customers at all before spending anything.

How to switch from paper to digital without upsetting anyone

  1. 01

    Run both for a few weeks

    Put the sign-up QR poster next to the till and keep honouring paper cards. Say a fixed end date, for instance the end of the month.

  2. 02

    Carry over the stamps

    When a regular hands in a half-full paper card, sign them up and add the same number of stamps to their digital card in one go. Nobody loses what they have earned.

  3. 03

    Keep a stack of paper cards for those who want them

    A customer without a smartphone should not be left out. A few paper cards in a drawer cost nothing.

  4. 04

    Bin the old stamp

    Once the transition date has passed, stop stamping paper cards so that nobody runs two cards at once.

What the digital card does not do

A digital card with Passcard is not an app: the customer installs nothing and creates no account. It is not a plastic card either; there is nothing to post or hand out. It does not send SMS, and it does not connect to your till or card machine: stamps are added by scanning the card. If a customer deletes the card from the wallet, it can no longer be updated on that phone, but their history stays on your side and they get it back by rescanning your QR code.

Pricing

£19 per month

or £190 per year, 2 months free

Prices exclude tax.

Frequently asked questions

01

Is a digital loyalty card worth it for a small café?

It depends on what you want. If you only want "tenth coffee free", paper is cheaper. If you want to know who your regulars are and bring back those who have stopped coming, a digital card does what paper cannot.

02

Can I transfer stamps from paper cards to digital ones?

Yes. When a customer brings a paper card, sign them up and add the same number of stamps to the digital card at once. Extra stamps added in one go are deliberate and allowed.

03

What about customers without a smartphone?

Keep a few paper cards for them. A digital card needs an iPhone or an Android phone with Apple Wallet or Google Wallet.

04

Is a digital card safer against fraud?

Yes, because each stamp is recorded with its date and the member of staff who added it, and a 10-second cooldown blocks accidental double scans. A paper stamp leaves no trace.

05

Do digital cards get lost?

Much less often, because they live in the phone. If a customer deletes theirs, they scan your sign-up QR code again and you still have their history.

06

How much does the digital card cost?

One plan in the UK: £19 a month excluding VAT or £190 a year, with unlimited customers and cards. New businesses get 14 days free, and customers never pay.

Ready to launch your loyalty card?

Create your card
  • No app for your customers
  • Apple Wallet and Google Wallet
  • Set up in a few minutes