How much does a loyalty scheme cost a small business?

In short

The cost of a loyalty scheme for a small business has four parts: the software, the rewards you give away, a little printing and a few seconds of staff time per customer. In most independents the rewards are the biggest line, so the reward has to be priced against your margin, not its shelf price. Passcard costs £19 a month excluding VAT in the UK, with unlimited customers and cards.

14 free days to try everything. Serve 30 customers in your first 14 days: 1 extra month free on your subscription.

Paid plans from £19 a month, excluding tax.

Example card

The four costs of any loyalty scheme

Owners often judge a loyalty scheme on the subscription alone. That is the most visible line but rarely the biggest. A scheme costs what you pay for the tool, what you give away, what you print and the time your team spends on it. Then there are a few hidden costs worth naming before you start.

What a loyalty scheme costs a UK independent
CostWhat it coversHow to keep it under control
SoftwareThe digital card, scanning, messagesOne flat plan: £19 a month excluding VAT with Passcard
RewardsThe free items or discounts customers claimPrice the reward at cost, not at the menu price
PrintingQR poster, maybe a table card or window stickerPrint the poster once: the QR code never changes
Staff timeAsking, scanning, explainingOne sentence at the till, a scanning station at the counter
Hidden costsFraud, abandoned cards, unclear rulesRecorded stamps, a card that is short enough to finish

The software

In the UK Passcard has one plan: £19 a month excluding VAT, or £190 a year. It includes unlimited customers and unlimited cards, Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, messages on the card and the figures of who comes back. A new business gets 14 days free to try it with real customers. Customers never pay anything.

There is no hardware to buy: your phone or an existing tablet is enough to scan cards. There is no SMS bill either, because messages appear on the card in the wallet rather than as text messages.

As the price is excluding VAT, a VAT-registered business can usually reclaim the VAT on the subscription as it would for other business software; check with your accountant.

The rewards: a worked example as a share of margin

The figures below are hypothetical, chosen to show the method. Say you run a café and a flat white sells for £3.40. Say the coffee, milk and cup cost you £0.85. Your card has ten boxes and, as by default, the 10th box is the free coffee: nine paid coffees, then one free.

Nine paid coffees bring in £30.60 of sales. The free one costs you £0.85. So the reward costs you about 2.8% of the sales it rewards, not 10% as "one free in ten" suggests, because you give it away at cost and not at the menu price. VAT is left aside here for simplicity.

Now the side effect. Many customers who come in for their free coffee also buy a pastry or bring a friend. If even a third of reward visits include a £2.80 pastry, the reward partly pays for itself on the day it is claimed.

Do the same sum for your own trade. For a barber, a free beard trim might take ten minutes of a chair that would otherwise be empty mid-afternoon: the real cost is mostly time you already pay for. For a chippy, a free portion of chips costs a fraction of its menu price in potatoes and oil.

Printing and staff time

A digital card removes the print runs of paper cards. You still print the QR poster (Passcard gives it to you as a PDF), perhaps a small card for each table or a window sticker. Because the sign-up QR code points to your shop and not to a version of the card, you print it once and change the reward later without reprinting.

Staff time is a few seconds per scan. Where it can add up is a busy morning rush: a scanning station at the counter (a paired phone or tablet) avoids passing one phone around. A 10-second technical cooldown blocks a double scan on the same customer, and extra stamps for several items are added deliberately.

Hidden costs to keep in mind

  • Fraud on paper cards: copied stamps or "kind" extra stamps. With a digital card every stamp is recorded with its date and who added it.
  • Abandoned cards: a card too long to finish costs you the sign-up effort and gives nothing back.
  • Over-generous rewards that you then have to withdraw, which annoys regulars more than a modest reward ever would.
  • Data handling: collecting more than you need creates UK GDPR duties for nothing. The ICO explains what applies to a small business.
  • Your own time deciding on messages. Keep it to a few useful ones a month.

When does the scheme pay for itself?

The reasoning is simple: the scheme pays when the extra visits it creates bring in more margin than it costs. Retention has a strong effect on profit: in research by Bain & Company led by Frederick Reichheld, a 5% increase in customer retention was associated with profit increases of 25% to 95% in the industries studied. Your café is not one of those industries, so use your own numbers.

Take the café above, with an assumed margin of £2.55 on each £3.40 coffee. Divide the monthly subscription, £19, by £2.55: that is the number of extra coffees a month the scheme needs to generate to cover the software. Add the cost of the rewards claimed, and compare with the extra visits you see in your figures after a few months. For many cafés, a couple of regulars coming in one extra time a week is the order of magnitude involved.

Monthly or yearly?

You can pay £19 a month or £190 a year, both excluding VAT. Monthly suits a shop trying a loyalty scheme for the first time, or a seasonal business on the coast that wants to see a full summer before committing. Yearly suits a shop that already knows the scheme works and would rather pay once and forget about it.

Either way the content is the same: unlimited customers, unlimited cards, both wallets and messages on the card. Start with the 14 free days, look at how many customers joined and came back, and decide with real figures in front of you.

What you will not pay for with Passcard

  • An app for your customers: there is none to build or maintain.
  • Plastic cards or postage.
  • SMS credits.
  • A till or card machine integration: Passcard works next to the till you already have.
  • Extra fees per customer or per card: the UK plan is unlimited.

Pricing

£19 per month

or £190 per year, 2 months free

Prices exclude tax.

Frequently asked questions

01

How much does a digital loyalty card cost in the UK?

With Passcard, £19 a month excluding VAT or £190 a year, with unlimited customers and cards. New businesses get 14 days free.

02

Is there a free plan in the UK?

No. The UK has a single plan with everything included, and a free trial of 14 days for a new business.

03

What is the biggest cost of a loyalty scheme?

Usually the rewards. Price them at what they cost you to make, not at their menu price, and compare that with the sales needed to earn them.

04

Do I need to buy a scanner?

No. You scan cards with your phone, or a phone or tablet left at the counter as a scanning station.

05

Are there SMS costs for messages?

No. Messages appear on the card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, so there is no SMS bill.

06

Can I reclaim VAT on the subscription?

The price is shown excluding VAT. Whether and how you reclaim VAT depends on your own VAT registration: ask your accountant.

07

Do customers pay anything?

Never. Joining the scheme and keeping the card in the wallet is free for them.

Ready to launch your loyalty card?

Create your card
  • No app for your customers
  • Apple Wallet and Google Wallet
  • Set up in a few minutes